By Dr. Saya Nagori
Medical Director/Simple Contacts
The Kentucky General Assembly is currently considering legislation, House Bill 191, that is bad for innovation, bad for consumers and bad for the health care system overall. House Bill 191 would radically restrict emerging ocular telemedicine technologies and undermine physicians’ ability to treat patients in the way they see fit.
Physicians go through rigorous schooling, training, licensing and certification, and ultimately, we trust doctors to make the best treatment decisions for their patients. With HB 191, optometrists, who are not medical doctors, are trying to use legislation to dictate how medical doctors deliver care.
The issue behind these provisions is an emerging telemedicine technology that addresses a simple problem: 79 percent of the time a contact lens user visits an optometrist to renew a prescription, they leave with the same prescription they arrived with. These trips, and the accompanying examinations, are costly and time-consuming, causing many patients to wear their lenses beyond the recommended timeframe. Over-wearing contact lenses is one of the leading cause of eye infections and other medical issues for contact lens wearers.
Innovations in mobile technology allow patients today to refill their contact lens prescriptions in a much more efficient and cost-effective way. Mobile app platforms such as Simple Contacts administer a basic vision test and anterior segment assessment that’s a fraction of the cost of an in-person optometrist visit and can be done from the comfort of a patient’s home.

Each test is recorded and reviewed by a Kentucky licensed ophthalmologist who can renew the patient’s existing contact lens prescription. The physician cannot change, modify or issue a patient’s very first contact lens prescription — in the event of a change that could signify ocular or other health concerns, the patient must have an in-person appointment.
This is not a replacement for a full eye exam. Instead, it is a way for physicians to treat low-risk, asymptomatic patients safely while saving time, money and resources for everyone involved. The technology works, and no physician would ever risk their reputation and license or endanger patient safety if they did not believe it to be completely safe or in line with medical best practices. In fact, the American Academy of Ophthalmology currently recommends comprehensive, in-person eye health exams for healthy adults who do not have risk factors for eye disease every five to ten years for patients under 40; two to four years for patients 40-54; one to three years for patients 55-64 years and one to two years for patients 65 years and older.
However, like other entrenched industries facing new competition, optometrists are using scare tactics and misinformation to vilify their competitors and have appealed to the legislature to intervene as just another business strategy.
HB 191 restricts telemedicine in such a way that physicians would no longer be allowed to use innovative, cost-effective services like Simple Contacts to renew a patient’s prescription. Kentucky should be embracing technologies that save health care costs, create efficiencies and encourage patient choice, rather than shutting them out.
Opponents of the technology have done much to muddy the waters with false claims that automated kiosks or a smartphone app are issuing prescriptions and that patients have been harmed through using our technology. Of the thousands of patients who have used Simple Contacts for vision exams, not a single one has reported any issues.
As a board-certified ophthalmologist, I can attest to the safety and efficacy of Simple Contacts’ platform. Requiring low-risk, adult patients to visit an optometrist or ophthalmologist in-person simply to leave with the same brand and strength contact lens is wasteful, especially when a medically valid and safe telemedicine alternative exists. HB 191 is nothing short of protectionism dressed up as patient protection, driven not by medical standards, but by the economic interests of a special interest group.
Ensuring patient safety should always be health care providers’ number one priority. That’s why everyone can agree that creating commonsense regulations to ensure only licensed physicians or optometrists are using technology to write or renew contact lens prescriptions is a valid and worthy objective. But these regulations shouldn’t come at the expense of innovation and a patient’s right to choose the care that works best for them.
Dr. Nagori is Medical Director at Simple Contacts, Chief of Glaucoma Service at Mount Sinai St Lukes, and Clinical Instructor at NYU Dept. of Ophthalmology and NYU school of medicine.








